Hitler, Stalin and Walter O’Malley

A short film about loyalty, Brooklyn in the 1950s, and the Dodgers moving to Los Angeles.

by R.M. Cohen

OlioNovember 22, 2026

I fell for the Brooklyn Dodgers … hard. Even though the team had deserted Brooklyn and its ballpark, Ebbets Field, had been razed before I was born.

This is the way it happened.

My adopted grandfather, Jules, loved the Dodgers. He had moved to California before owner Walter O’Malley dragged the Brooklyn Dodgers west for the ’58 season. He thought it was a terrible injustice that the team had left its fans in Brooklyn…despondent.

I asked my husband, David, who grew up a Dodgers fan, about this mythic team. He gave me Peter Golenbock’s Bums: An Oral History of the Brooklyn Dodgers. That’s how it started.

I was smitten.

David was a Dodgers fan because his dad, Fritz, was a Dodgers fan. Fritz fell in love with Brooklyn baseball after returning to his new home in America. He’d fled Vienna in ’38 and gone on to serve under Patton. When the Dodgers left Brooklyn, Fritz never listened to another ballgame. Fritz survived Hitler and the Blitz. The Dodgers leaving Brooklyn was the loss he never got over.

Former senator Pat Roberts of Kansas told a similar story. He gave up on baseball when the Dodgers left Brooklyn. I asked him, “You were in Kansas. What did you care if they moved left or right?”

He just did.

I found all of this incredibly intriguing, so I set out to read every Dodgers book I could find. I devoured the words of sportswriters Tommy Holmes and Dave Anderson of the Brooklyn Eagle. Those men were true wordsmiths. I found cassette tapes of Brooklyn Dodgers games. The Dodgers’ radio guys, Red Barber and Vin Scully, weren’t half-bad either.

I ate up these long-past games as if they were being played in real time. I soon joined the ranks of fans who loved a Brooklyn team they’d never seen play. I never saw Oisk pitch or Campanella behind the plate. I didn’t see Jack Roosevelt Robinson dancing off third or stealing home, though once I got a handwritten note from Yogi, who still insisted that Robinson was “OUT.” As for Bobby Thomson’s 1951 home run, the “Shot Heard ’Round the World,” Ralph Branca convinced me that “the Giants were stealing the signs!”

Roger Kahn and I became fast friends. Even his emails read like poetry. Tom Oliphant would take me to lunch and tell me tales about the Brooklyn Dodgers. Kahn wrote The Boys of Summer, and Oliphant wrote Praying for Gil Hodges.

Those two old guys and this girl made a merry group at the 50th-anniversary celebrations of the Brooklyn Dodgers’ only World Series win. My short film Hitler, Stalin & Walter O’Malley premiered on the Jumbotron at KeySpan Park in Coney Island. Oisk, Clem Labine, Ed Roebuck, and George Shuba showed up. Fans came out in force! I heard many an inside joke about Hitler, Stalin, and Walter O’Malley. For a certain generation of Brooklynites, the line was that Walter O’Malley destroyed what even Hitler and Stalin could not.

The home front.

A few years later, Tom Oliphant arranged for me to speak to John Sexton’s famous NYU class, “Baseball as a Road to God.” I was writing a play about Satchel Paige, Bill Veeck, and baseball’s first commissioner, Kenesaw Mountain Landis. But that’s a story for another day…

For my adopted grandfather, my father-in-law, and a senator from Kansas who never listened to another inning of baseball. For the Brooklyn Eagle writers who wrote about Brooklyn like it was its own goddamn country. For the Brooklyn faithful who never forgot or forgave.

I wrote this film for them.